CorrectKMI panel rulingGoalSignificantQuiet

Brennan Johnson goal given after VAR review

MCIManchester City0 – 2Tottenham HotspurTOT

Saturday, 23 August 2025 · 2025-26 · 37'

What happened

The goal was initially not given, but awarded after a VAR review. The decision does not appear among the errors the KMI panel logged for 2025-26, which means the panel voted it correct.

On the pitch: No goal
VAR: VAR overturned
Benefited: TOT Tottenham Hotspur
Harmed: MCI Manchester City

Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how Manchester City fans, Tottenham Hotspur fans and everyone else answered.

Sources

Officials & their calls

RefereePeter BankesNot judgedcareer on file: 8 err · 58%VARAndy MadleyCorrectcareer on file: 10 err · 33%Assistant VARSian Massey-EllisCorrectcareer on file: 1 err · 93%

What the fans thought

Quiet10

5 of 1089 comments in the r/soccer post-match thread were angry about the officiating, mostly from Tottenham Hotspur fans. Main gripes: penalty and handball.

“That sequence where they missed two fouls on the edge of the box in a row (including the handball/knee to chest by trafford) was one of the worst I’ve seen” · 202 upvotes · ARS fan

“Real talk, Asahi is actually quite nice. Realer talk, f*** Man City and f*** their official beer sponsor. Beavertown til I die (never tasted it).” · 34 upvotes · TOT fan

Whole-match mood, not this incident alone.

Something wrong or missing?

This record is community-maintained. If there's a panel ruling, a better source or a correction, send it in.

Edit on GitHub Report a correction

What happened

Sources

Related incidents

Awoniyi sent off for catching De Cuyper with an arm in the air

Brighton penalty for a foul on Kostoulas

Foden sent off for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes

Haaland derby winner stands despite Enzo Fernández offside